Showing posts with label Platinum Garden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Platinum Garden. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Platinum Garden: Vol. 7

by Maki Fujita

Synopsis
Marriages ought to be based on trust and understanding, but lately Kazura's engagement seems to be nothing but secrets and mysteries. First, Shintaro Aguri, a substitute teacher who is really a member of the Magahara family, challenges her to find a former classmate's mysterious parting gift or else break up with Mizuki. Then Mizuki performs a soul return on a friend's husband, leaving Mizuki in the hospital, exhausted and wracked by fits, and poor Kazura (is) clueless as to why!


Review
Marriage. Ha, don't make me laugh. We won't see any marriage in this manga.

Well, apparently there's a woman who can see the future in the Magahara family. Fine, whatever. She thinks that Kazura and Mizuki should break up because of an unhappy future. Kazura bravely asks to see what it is, and she shows her. Unfortunately, the audience is not worthy of seeing what this horrible future is, probably so Fujita can keep us in the dark, and drag out her story. Seriously, what the hell? I was expecting to find out what the horrible future was, and was really disappointed that I didn't get to. I always worry, because things that are kept secret like this end up being not as bad as imagined. In other words, what you can make up in your imagination from not knowing is worse than reality. Meaning, a huge disappointment in the end, when it all comes to light.

Then there's the end, where we actually see Mizuki perform a soul return. He says that he did this to punish himself, because he's not worthy of Kazura and her kindness. Because, the author has totally established this beforehand, so it doesn't feel like it comes out of left field. Right, whatever. Oh, and right before that, he says he has to tell her how he feels about her, before it's too late. But you know what happens!? Everything gets interrupted and he never says it. Cliche.

I don't know about this series. I'm disappointed by this volume. Too much humor, not enough development. Lately, I've realized that I've had my own ideas about where this manga should have gone, and that I like my idea better than hers. I think it should have been a real romance, where the characters were initially opposed to the arrangement, but as they got to know each other, they realized that they like each other. Everything about the family could have remained exactly the same, with people trying to drive them apart, and having supernatural powers. Except it would be the two of them, a united front, against the world. Well, what a shame.

Final thought: Do I care? I don't think so.

Monday, February 9, 2009

Platinum Garden: Vol. 6


by Maki Fujita

Synopsis
Old scars bear new wounds in Maki Fujita's shojo masterpiece... Kazura travels to the Magahara estate looking for answers, but instead finds herself an unwitting guest at an elaborate party! With Mizuki off training with the judo club and Shizuku disposed by doddering old relatives, Kazura's rescue from the taunting Magahara family members will come from the least likely of people -- Mizuki's sister, who has a grudge against Mizuki!

Review
All right, I've come to a decision about this series. It is not a romance. I will not see it as a romance, expect romance from it, or hope for romance anymore. It's just a story about a girl promised to a certain person, and she uses her spunk and sassiness to improve others' lives. Maybe now I can stop being disappointed about the lack of development of Kazura and Mizuki. I suppose they will always remain the way they have since volume one: silently caring about each other, but outwardly hostile.

This volume introduces more characters for Kazura to help: Mizuki's half-sister, Akari. She was supposed to be in Mizuki's place, apparently, but was unexpectedly deposed. Really, a lot about this family has been revealed: their odd powers, their dependence of the head to keep them alive, and now that these "soul returns" use up the user's life energy. They're a formidable force for Kazura to have to deal with, and I think her brashness is refreshing, considering how uptight the Magahara family is. This series continues to be interesting, despite the lack of romance, and I'm really curious about what more secrets we'll find out about this family.

Final thought: I'll keep reading.

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Platinum Garden: Vol. 5

by Maki Fujita

Synopsis
Kazura and Mizuki's "relationship" is on shaky ground in this latest volume of Maki Fujita's shojo fling.... After forcing Kazura to move back home with her family, an embarrassed Mizuki finally asks her to live with him again. Just when things seem like they're back to "normal," she's tricked in a secret meeting with the Magahara family monarch, who shocks Kazura with a very disturbing question. How will Kazura respond?

Review
I expected more from this volume. Not much really happens, I guess. Kazura decides to go ask Mizuki if she can live with him again, rather than mope around, which is nice, I guess. What I really want to say is that I wish there was more between them. I'm really getting tired of people saying how good they are together, how Kazura's on Mizuki's side, and that Mizuki really does like her, but doesn't say it. I mean, it's supposed to be a romance, for god's sake, can I have some romance, please? Please show me something! I don't even care if Mizuki is a jerk to everyone else, but is nice to Kazura, that would be enough for me. Or am I supposed to interpret Mizuki's insults and threats as "his way of showing love"? If so, I don't buy it at all. I guess I could say that since he always rescues Kazura, or comes running when she's hurt, that he does care about her.... Maybe. Maybe I just want more.

There's some filler stories about Kazura's rival, Shizuku, planning more nefarious problems for Kazura, and another about some upperclassman who's unhappy with himself, so Kazura takes it upon herself to try and help him. I could take these better if there was some development for Kazura and Mizuki, so I'm probably a bit embittered right now.

Then there's some cliffhanger at the end. I hope it means we get back to some development!

Final thought: I'll keep reading.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

Platinum Garden: Vol. 4

by Maki Fujita

Synopsis
Revelations surface in Maki Fujita's romantic shojo... Toya Magahara opens up to Kazura and tells her about the Magahara family -- including a life-and-death secret that could change their lives. Then, with the New Year approaching, Kazura spends some more time with Mizuki. When she sees a side of him not even his family knows, Kazura learns that happiness can hurt sometimes -- and some wounds never heal.

Review
I'm not really sure what to make of this volume. Some stuff gets explained, like why Mizuki is the head of the family, and the services he performs for them, and Kazura regains her memories of her childhood friendship with Mizuki. But I feel like nothing really develops. Mizuki is still very much a jerk to her, and they don't talk much nor spend much time together. Ultimately, Mizuki sends her away for "a while" which upsets Kazura. I'm really starting to feel sorry for her, because it's clear that she really cares about him, but can't really read his feelings for her. Also, other people say how lucky he is to have her, etc., but Mizuki doesn't even seem to need her, nor does he act appreciative in any way that he has her.

I'm really curious to find out what it all means and what's going to happen, but it's a little frustrating to read at times, seeing characters hurt and not knowing what's going on.

Final thought: I'll read the next book.

Monday, January 12, 2009

Platinum Garden: Vol. 3

by Maki Fujita

Synopsis
Maki Fujita's romantic shojo romp continues.... As the school-wide chase for Kazura ends, the truth behind why student council president Shizuku Magahara orchestrated this madness is finally revealed. With this secret out and finally behind them, Kazura and Shizuku begin to bond. Later, the group has a getaway at a remote cottage -- where things become a bit too cozy!

Review
The most interesting part of this volume was how things subtly change, such as Kazura's feelings towards Mizuki. I think it starts when Shizuku offers to give Kazura money, presumably as a bribe, but I also saw it as a way that Kazura could have paid off the debt and left. She refuses, and the story changes from one of obligation to one of choice. Kazura has now chosen to stay with Mizuki. This also changes her opinion of him, as she sees more of him with his family, she sees how he puts on the "fake" face for them too. She realizes that he's not fake, he does it to protect himself, and she soon realizes that she's one of the only people who can be on his side. I noticed that after this she doesn't say, "I hate him" or "He's so fake" anymore.

Mizuki is developed some more in this volume, such as how he grew up, and things his family did to him. It also seems like he's not the only one with unusual powers in the family. There's a little more time given to the couple, but not nearly as much as I'd like.

This volume really changed my opinion of this series. I liked it before, but now I take it a lot more seriously. I can only hope that it continues to stay this good, or even get better as it goes on.

Final thought: I have to get the next volume!

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Platinum Garden: Vol. 2

by Maki Fujita

Synopsis
Kazura's life has been in constant turmoil. First, her grandfather "gave" her to a boy named Mizuki to be his fiancee! Then, when she moved in with Mizuki, she learned that he resurrects the dead for rich clients! Now comes Kazura's biggest crisis to date: transferring to Mizuki's snooty rich high school. But trouble brews when the jealous student body learns she's Mizuki's "girlfriend" -- and sabotages their relationship!

Review
This kinda plays out as a high school drama in this volume, with girls wanting to make Kazura's life hell just because she's Mizuki's fiancee. But Kazura is a strong girl, something I really like, and she doesn't put up with any of their crap. She stands up for herself and makes them sorry that they tried to pick on her. Along the way, she makes new (if odd) friends, a guy named Kagami and Tsukiko the "high school killer."

The girls constantly try to use Kazura's friendship with Kagami as evidence of adultery, which I would worry about if it worked out, but fortunately, it seems like Mizuki isn't that stupid. He knows that Kagami is her friend, even if he doesn't like it, and it seems like he trusts Kazura to do the right thing.

What isn't shown a whole lot is the relationship between Mizuki and Kazura. I would like to see more of that. I guess it's assumed that they just go on as normal, with Kazura complaining about how fake he is and how much she hates him. I hope the series has more of their relationship, as they've developed Mizuki quite a bit, and I'm really curious if Kazura can help him or not.

Final thought: I'll keep collecting this series.

Thursday, November 27, 2008

Platinum Garden: Vol. 1

by Maki Fujita

Synopsis(from the back of the book)
When Kazura is sent to live in Mizuki's house, she learns that she's really there to become his wife! Furious, Kazura tries to leave, but discovers that she was given as payment for her deceased grandfather's debts. But things aren't what they seem to be in this household -- Mizuki can call back people's souls, and Kazura wants him to bring back her grandfather!

Maki Fujita's shojo comedy is filled with delicious family secrets, dream high-school romance, and plenty of spirited fun.

Review
Another manga with a weird premise, but not one that I dislike, because it depends on what happens with it.

Understandably, Kazura is unhappy about being sold to the Magahara family, and this is compounded by the fact that she is to be Mizuki's fiancee, and that he's a real jerk. She takes it well though, and does her best. But she's not one to be cowed, and although some hitting does happen in this book, it's not often, and it's usually deserved (for once). What I thought was enjoyable to watch was Kazura and Mizuki fighting. It's weird, because I don't care for fighting, but these two just push each other's buttons so well, and are equally good at fighting that it's kinda fun to watch and see who wins.

As I kept reading, I found that some development does happen for both characters, and I started really caring about both of them. Mizuki is really sullen for a reason, and it's possible that only spunky Kazura can help him. (Only in books. This doesn't work in real life.)

In the final chapter, we see her finally going to school, as she's been kept in the house the whole time, and as usual, the girls are horrible bitches who misunderstand everything and see Mizuki as something that belongs to them. I know this generates conflict, but it's really cliche, and I've seen it before. Maybe only in Japan, I don't know because I've never been to school there, does this kind of thing happen. My real problem with it is there is never anybody who notices the girls fighting with each other and puts a stop to it. I mean, where are the teachers and parents? The kids are always left to figure it out themselves. It just doesn't ring true.

Also, the mysticism doesn't show up much here, but it probably will in future volumes. I'm not sure how I feel. It seems tacked on compared to the story so far, and I hope it's not used to drag out the romance part. I guess we'll see.

I know Tokyopop wants to do their 100% Authentic manga or whatever, but this means that they didn't translate the sound effects. Usually, this isn't a problem, but this manga seems to rely on sound cues for what happens in the next panel, leading to confusion for people who can't read Japanese. I am not one of these people, but I can empathize. The least they could have done was to put some translation in the gutter between panels, that way it wouldn't interfere with the artwork. Of course there's a fine line between censorship and comprehension, I just think they didn't try very hard with the comprehension part.

Final thought: I have to get the next book!